2016 Customer Reviews

12/28/2016 – Michael Schulteis
Burlington, WI 53105

The entire process was flawless. Their subcontractors were very efficient and hard working. I would not hesitate in the least to use their company again. The day after they were done they arrange pickup of the dumpster that was used and made sure the yard and driveway were cleaned up. They came early each day and also worked late. Great work ethic ended with a fantastic finished product.

12/23/2016 – Chris Mieska
Waukesha, WI 53186

Like most people I suppose, I wanted a high quality, good looking, energy efficient door that didn’t cost an arm and a leg. I worked with Scott. Scott listened to what I was looking for, I’m sure I wasn’t using the correct verbage, but he understood what I was saying. After understanding what I what I wanted, I was provided with multiple options and combinations to choose from. I never knew there were so many choices, I guess I never really paid attention to front doors like I do now. I narrowed it down to a couple of choices and Elite provided me with quotes for each one. I had gotten quotes from some of the other that advertise on the radio with fancy jingles and Elite was by far the most competitive price. After I selected the door that I wanted, they came out to take the measurements for the new door. The were very accomidating when it came time to schedule this. Elite submitted my order and communicated the expeced schedule. I received periodic updates as the expected arrival date came nearer. You can buy the most expense door in the world but if it isn’t installed correclty, you just wasted your money. Elite sent out a two man crew and got started first thing in the morning. The crew was very professional, polite, clean and diligent when it came to the installation. They removed and hauled away the old door. They installed and insulated the new frame and made sure everything fit like it should. They also installed new hardward and made sure the locks and latches worked properly. I don’t think they would have done anything differetly if they were working on thier own house. I believe my door installation was top notch. At the end of the day, a new front door is an investment in your home. I believe I received great value for the money I spent and I would not hesitate to use Elite Exteriors again nor would I hesiate to recommend them to family and friends.

12/14/2016 – Walter Alt
Germantown, WI 53022

They were courteous, conscientious and payed attention to my concerns and desires. They cleaned up every night. They worked hard every day and got the job done in good time. It looks great and I have gotten many great comments from my neighbors.

12/13/2016 – Lane Donahue
Burlington, WI 53105

Minor issue with fascia appearance- corrected immediately by Dave’s crew

12/9/2016 – Tom Otto
Brookfield, WI 53005

Reasonable price and excellent work done. Scott did not attempt a ‘high pressure’ sell job – just the options and facts. We made a few revisions before the work began (reasonable) and were tickled pink at the end results.

11/21/2016 – Cathy Dunn
Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

From quote to clean-up, it all went well. Would highly recommend Elite for a new roof.

11/18/2016 – Elizabeth Huwiler
Elm Grove, WI 53122

We were very satisfied. The bid was competitive. The workers arrived on schedule, did an efficient job (removing old roof, replacing rotted wood beneath it, and replaced the roof and vents. Cleanup was thorough, except for small pieces of clear plastic film we’ve found around the place. After the workers were gone, the boss came by to check on everything. All in all, a fine job and we would call them again.

11/15/2016 – Colleen Vap
Cedarburg, WI 53012

Elite did an excellent job on our roof and Hardie Plank siding project! We are so pleased with the results! Great communication and attention to detail throughout the project

10/13/2016 – Steve Hale
New Berlin, WI 53151


10/12/2016 – Matt Delisle
Brookfield, WI 53045

Scott and his crew did a great job updating the look of our house, we couldn’t be more happy with how everything turned out. Scott provided his professional opinion on colors and options to help ease our indecisiveness. He also provided several houses from past jobs so we could see how everything would look as a finished product. Project took about a week to complete, and with any major remodel there will be issues. I was impressed with how quickly Scott responded and resolved everything to our satisfaction at no additional cost. We will be hiring Scott and Elite to do our windows as our next big project.

9/6/2016 – Michael Chybowski
Franklin, WI 53132

Overall excellent job. Crew was very efficient, clean and very competent. The new gutters are beautiful and were much better installed than the previous gutters on the house. We are very pleased with the job and would highly recommend Elite Exteriors.

9/5/2016 – Jose Perez
Milwaukee, WI 53215

The work done was great! The owner Scott was readily available to answer any question at any time. The men worked quickly and did a great job cleaning up! Very satisfied with my new siding and very pleased with the affordable price.

8/22/2016 – Marcia Stojsavljevic
St. Francis, WI 53235

The elite exteriors crew is amazing! Scott (owner) came out to do the estimate, and gave me sound advice and a very fair estimate (yes I did get others). Then the crew (Rob and John) came in to remove old windows and install the new ones, and they were extremely professional and it was a non-event. Next came the trim crew (who I never met because they came when I was at work) and my neighbors commented on how they really took the time and did things right. Finally the stainer who made sure I was happy with the color before doing any of the windows. Some of the screens had pin holes (shipping?) but they were rescreened the same day. When I opened the widow too far to clean and came off the track…Scot sent someone out to help get it back in. Just amazing customer service, he really wants to be sure you are happy. My family member was so impressed that she used them as well and was equally as pleased with the product, service, and experience.

8/5/2016 – Joseph Hurley
Waukesha, WI 53188

Everything went very well. The crew showed up on the day promised and began to work. We had a couple of very hot days, the crew was up on the roof even though the heat index was in the 100’s. They were very professional and courteous. My only complaint was the cleanup of the yard was as thorough as we would have liked initially. I spoke with Scott and he had someone come out again the next day to do another check for nails and such in the yard. I was very happy with how they responded to the situation. The roof looks fantastic! I am very impressed with this company.

7/31/2016 – Catherine Lageson
Wauwatosa, WI 53213

I will be forever grateful for their willingness to help me out with my storm window issues. They were the only window contractor that I contacted that was willing to work with me. I also bought 4 new windows for my older home. The crew was very professional and the work was completed as promised.

7/30/2016 – Gerald Grzesk
Franklin, WI 53132

These guys were fantastic in the heat they worked all day and were very prompt and curtious All work was completed as per contract with no extra costs. Clean up was spot on, finished job on time as promised

7/22/2016 – Robert Mielcarek
Milwaukee, WI 53221

Great work, great price. We’ll hire them again.

7/21/2016 – Sandy Hamm
Waukesha, WI 53189

This is my first ever review here on Angie’s List. I’m not sure just what to say that is of value to others. I guess I’ll start with the number one question I would ask, and then get more detailed. Question: Would you use Elite Exteriors again for roofing and/or recommend them to family and friends? Answer: Yes. We invited a few roofing contractors to come to the house and bid the job for a complete new roof. Scott, the owner at Elite Exteriors, responded personally and immediately to our inquiry. By “immediately,” I mean that day (by phone). The next day he was onsite at our home. Scott went over all the details with us (Master Elite Contractor for GAF products), available Warranties, estimates for Start and End Dates (the Full Monty). When he was at the house he estimated all the dimensions, but the next day he ordered, at his expense, an EagleView Report of the house. EagleView is a company that provides aerial photographs of property which can include peaks, valleys, square footage, etc. An EagleView Report is used a lot and saves roofers from having to crawl up on the roof with a tape measure, etc. and it is very accurate. Like a very close-up Google Earth but specialized for roofers and contractors. I’ll skip over all the details, but not only was Elite’s bid lower than the others, but Scott was more thorough in his descriptions of products and methods, and we believed was installing superior products. He ordered the EagleView Report on June 25 and we had a full quote three day later. On Wednesday June 29, Scott called to say he had a crew become available for the next week and they could start July 5, the Tuesday after the 4th of July. We all agreed. So, before I finish up, I need to address the roofing crew of 5-6 men. These guys were just plain fantastic, arriving at about 6:45 a.m. and worked until 7:45 p.m. the first day. They were so good that the first day we decided to provide them all pizza, soda, water, etc. for lunch. At the end of that Tuesday I tipped each of the five roofers $20 cash out of my pocket because they had worked so hard and steady. They were a pleasure to have working on our home. The second day they arrived about 7:15 a.m. and started right in. I asked the lead guy if they would like ribs for lunch, but he opted for turkey sandwiches on Italian bread. My wife and I went to the store and got all the stuff, and pickles, and tomatoes, chips, drinks and the 6 of them had a great lunch. They plowed through the day until about 7:30 p.m., at which time they had completely replaced our 3,000 square foot roof, including 5 Ridges (86′), 8 Hips (85′), 9 Valleys (98′), 13 Rakes (192′), drip edge… on and on. Again, each got $20 for their superior performance, except I tipped the lead guy a $50. A completed job on a very complicated roof done in two days! We were smiling to say the least. I am 65-years old and we bought the GAF 50-year warranty, so I am not planning on putting on another roof in my lifetime, but if I had to, I’d have Elite back to do it.

7/11/2016 – Elizabeth Reinke
New Berlin, WI 53151

It went awesome. Came out identified the problem and quickly had people out to fix it.

7/6/2016 – Chuck Frentzel
New Berlin, WI 53151

Project was done in three phases. All the crews were courteous and professional. They kept to schedule or kept me informed if weather dictated a delay. Very satisfied with quality. I very much appreciated that Scott did the job the right way, not just “well that was what the contract called for”, at minimal variation in price. All crews kept area cleaned up.

4/7/2016 – Matthew Tritz
New Berlin, WI 53151

From the start I experienced nothing but the best from Elite Exteriors. We had a leaky roof and Elite Exteriors saved our house. They came out the same day I called and took a look at our problem. They gave us a few different options depending on our budget and long term plans with our home. Honest opinions about our problem and our options, with no pressure or gimmicks, and a very competitive estimate. After we decided to use them for our repairs they quickly set up an appointment that work best for our family. On the day of service the crew arrived promptly at 7am to begin the demo of the old roof. Very kind and professional crew. They completed the entire job by 2pm, and didn’t leave a single scrap of debris anywhere around the house. Overall excellent company that I would recommend for anyone I know!

3/11/2016 – Rich Crews
New Berlin, WI 53151

Scott was very responsive and kept in contact about the job throughout. He offered flexible payment options to match the timing of me getting an annual bonus. We had to work around the weather, and I also had another contractor doing work on the inside. Scott’s team was able to work around that contractor with no problem. It took 2 days, mainly because the contractors trailer kept them from delivering the shingles directly to the roof. The gutter guys came a few days after that and got the new ones in within a half day. Scott was on site the first day, and Dave was there the second and when the gutter guys came. The pipe leading from the sump pump out to the swale got broken during the tear off…Dave fixed it. Very happy with the results.

2/9/2016 – Raymond Juehring
River Hills, WI 53217

It went great. They were very professional and did an excellent job. The weather didn’t cooperate like it could have but rest assured there is a calming quality about Dave Watry that makes you feel like everything is going to be all right when your freaking out…lol. The job got completed and it looks really good.

2/5/2016 – Phillip Barnekow
Waukesha, WI 53186

We are very pleased with our new windows and the attention to detail paid by your team. This may have been the most hassle-free installation we have ever had, from the initial meeting with Scott through the install. There was no high pressure sales pitch, and the installers did a wonderful job on the finishing work inside and outside of the house. They cleaned up well. They did everything great the first time!

2/3/2016 – Shawn Bolender
Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

It went very well. We were pleasantly surprised that they would actually remove/install siding in winter. The crew showed up in early January and worked straight through until the job was done. Roberto, the crew leader, was wonderful. He and his crew were friendly, conscientious and did outstanding work. They picked up after themselves every day and communication was excellent. Scott was very helpful throughout the entire project. He helped us choose the right color, explained in detail how the process would go, and addressed all questions/concerns a timely manner. He stayed in contact with us throughout to ensure everything was going well.

1/30/2016 – Elizabeth Prusko
Elm Grove, WI 53122

We have a 90 year old bungalow that was last sided in 1971 over the original wood lap siding. The siding was in very bad shape so we contacted Elite Exteriors for a bid. We were very impressed with the care they took during the bidding process and we selected them right away. They explained all of our options from material to color. We chose HardiePlank as the material and we could not be happier with the results. Elite Exteriors took great care to respect the age of the home by suggesting a 4” siding exposure and doing a fantastic job of framing out the houses many arched windows. The craftsmanship, attention to detail and professionalism of the crew was top notch. Our house is now a standout on our block and we get lots of compliments from passers by. We will definitely work with Elite Exteriors again.

1/30/2016 – Elizabeth Prusko
Elm Grove, WI 53122

We contacted Elite Exteriors regarding ice damming issues on our roof. We only owned the house for 6 months at the time, but the neighbors informed us that the ice issues were not only severe with 4” icicles to hang from the roof, but had been occurring for well over 20 years. Elite Exteriors did a thorough assessment of the roof and attic and determined the cause was due to deteriorated and inadequate attic insulation. The work was scheduled and executed quickly. Their work has eliminated our ice damming issues and the entire house is much warmer.
The rain gutter system on our house was leaking and usually could not handle heavy rain storms causing water to run over the edges of the gutters. We contacted Elite Exteriors who first assessed the old gutter system and determined it was inadequate to handle the unique lines and size of the roof on our 90 year old bungalow. Instead of merely replacing the system we had with a new one, they increased the gutter and downspout sizes. The rain gutter system they installed not only looks great, but also performs fantastic.

1/12/2016 – Gayla Greis
Mequon, WI 53092

I am a very busy person. I am primary live in caretaker for my 91 year old dad, work full time and manage an apartment building. I wanted a company that I could trust, that I knew wouldn’t make more work for me; Elite Exteriors delivered just that. These guys rock! The first job they did for my dad was a roof and gutters on a large ranch style house. It was not a steep roof but a lot of angles and odd corners. I was amazed at how fast they worked and the workmen were very polite. They were very careful about the sides of the house and the siding. Anything that could get damaged was covered and neatly put back if moved. They were kind and considerate when my 91 year dad came out to look at the work, I thought that was incredibly nice, shows respect. I even enjoyed the roofer who sang as he worked. we are all America Idols one way or another. If I had questions, and I had lots, they politely answered all of them. Dave the gentleman who came out to look at the property, and give the quote was very pleasant and understanding. I was new at contracting work so Dave did a great job of giving me best practice advice which I really appreciated. Their quote was a little less than the other two companies I had looked at. With all honesty, it was my impression of the people that sold me. I suggested them to my coworker ? who she hired to do her roof, and my one of my best friends, who hired them for their roof. I was right, they did a great job. In fact, they did such a good job, I had them do the roof at my house a week later. Hassel free, clean, neat, great quality roof, polite and very understanding of their client’s needs.

1/5/2016 – Chelsea M Budde
Waukesha, WI 53186

The timeline began as it was supposed to, with the delivery of product and a dumpster. The siding crew worked tirelessly, efficiently, and so very hard — arriving early and staying late, despite the soaring summer heat. They were neat and clean, doing their best to provide a safe perimeter around the house, as we have two dogs. Though some of the men spoke little English, there was always someone on site who could translate as they worked, and someone who was an expert on the installation of the material. If we had a concern along the way — and believe me, my husband is a meticulous inspector — we were able to communicate it with the company and reach a solution in a reasonable timeframe.
The complication of our rotten chimney exterior was a big setback, but Scott was able to put a carpentry crew on it while the siding teardown and installation progressed on other areas of our exposed basement colonial. We believe he was honest about expenses along the way.
The whole project lasted three weeks, and it was a HUGE project. There was attention to finishing details, like putting up our new exterior lighting and vent covers. Even the garage windows, which did not come in at the proper depth, were trimmed out professionally by a carpenter to make them look nice inside and out. There was consideration for the landscaping around our home; though the plants were casualties of the project (they’ll grow back next spring), all the shrubs were in tact.
The transformation of our house was incredible! We had neighbors commenting on the job as it started, completed, and now, months later, they’re still talking about it and complimenting us! It really does look like a completely new home.
We would recommend Elite Exteriors to anyone considering James Hardie siding for their home. This was a once-in-a-lifetime investment, and we are confident we chose the right contractor for the job.

CLICK HERE to see 2012 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2013 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2014 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2015 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2016 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2017 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2018 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2019 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2020 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2021 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see 2022 Customer Reviews
CLICK HERE to see Current Customer Reviews